I Can’t Answer the “Why”

Multiple Miscarriage: I Can't Answer the "Why" - UnspokenGrief.com

They say that third times a charm, but that really doesn’t matter when its a matter of miscarriage.  As a matter of fact, in my case, third time was the most painful and gut wrenching of them all.

My name is Rose.  I’m a 30 year old mother to three handsome sons and three children that were just too precious for this world.  That’s what you say right?  When you lose your child–“they’re just to precious for this world???”  Not that I doubt that, really, I believe it with all my heart, but when you’re in the throes of a miscarriage, the third you’ve had in a row, you begin to grow rueful at adages like this.

So onward — Saturday, November 2, 2013  my husband and I have just received the proofs for the our baby announcement photos and had put our three sons, 6-years old, 4-years old and 2-years old, to bed when I felt a heavy pressure in my lower abdomen.  I ran into our bathroom and saw the blood.  My first thought was “not again”.  Each of my earlier losses had been very early in my pregnancy — early enough that I barely knew that I was pregnant.  This one, well, this was my miracle baby.

My last miscarriage was in September, and I had suffered my loss at home, just as I had the one before.  There was no need to leave home, the miscarriage was routine, until October when I found that I had been pregnant with multiples and that one of the precious babies had survived.  Now, I was losing the one child that had survived, eight weeks into my pregnancy, something that was unheard of to me.

My husband and I rushed to the hospital and after several hours were sent home, told that my cervix was still closed and I was perfectly fine.  Two days later I was back in the hospital with severe cramping and excessive bleeding. I sat there in a hospital bed, weeping with my husband holding my hand and looking as blank as he could.  That’s his coping mechanism — he protects ME by looking unfazed.

I couldn’t imagine what was going on.  Why?  Why was this  happening again?  Why was my body doing this to me?  Right now, the day after my miscarriage, I check my body, and the volume of my blood flow.  I cry every time I use the restroom and I scream at God.  The God that I worship, that I love and that I know works all things for the good of those who love him.  I scream because I can’t understand how this is good.  How it can in any way be good.  And I grieve.  I lay on my couch and hold the baby blanket that was intended for my precious little Abigail and I miss her.  I miss her and I never got to hold her.

My mind goes back and forth — I tell myself that God is still good, Jesus is still on his throne and I am still loved, but I don’t always believe it.  I want my baby.  I want people to understand where I’m coming from and to see that I’m not crazy.  I want to snuggle with my children — ALL of my children — and know that I’m safe, they’re safe and we’re together.  Most of all I want to know, without a doubt, that none of this was my fault.  That all the healthy eating and exercise wasn’t for naught.  I want to know that I didn’t do something to hurt my precious little baby … my Abigail.

And since I can’t answer the “whys” and the “hows” and the “what ifs” I just remind myself, “God is STILL good, Jesus is STILL on his throne and I am STILL loved” and hope that this time, I believe it.

— Rose

Photo credit: adapted from  Bilal Kamoon | Flickr

Comments are moderated before appearing. Please note: your comment here may show up on your Facebook Feed.

Our Stories

Collection of Community Submitted Stories. Author of each story is displayed at the end of the post. Want to share your story? Submit yours here.

  1. A heart-breaking, and beautifully honest post. I’m so very very sorry for the loss of your Abigail, and all your babies. The part about missing her even though you never got to hold her… I relate to that. Going through my 4th miscarriage now. Even as it’s my earliest loss at 5 weeks, I’m really struggling. Thanks again for this post.

  2. I am so sorry for your loss. This post really stuck out to me because firstly, my sister just had her 3rd miscarriage (not in a row…), and it has been hard for her and me because we are so close. She does have one little girl, and we both take comfort in knowing that, if nothing else, she has her! Secondly, Nov 2, 2013 is the date of my second daughter, Rosalie (Rose for short!)’s birth. It is so hard to imagine that when our family was so happy welcoming our newest precious addition, another mother was grieving a loss of hers that same day. I don’t think you can ever get ‘over’ a loss, but I hope you one day can somehow find peace and comfort through a loving God. xoxoxo

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

About Unspoken Grief

Unspoken Grief is a non-profit website dedicated to creating awareness and resources for anyone touched directly or indirectly by miscarriage, stillbirth or neonatal death.

©Unspoken Grief 2017; Devan McGuinness


Unspoken Grief exists to provide peer-to-peer support and resources. The information on this site is intended only for advocacy and educational purposes. It's not intended to give medical advice, to diagnose or to offer treatment for any medical or psychological conditions. Please consult your own health care provider for your own specific situation and needs.